THE SKY AS A RECORD · LESSON 1 OF 3 · READ · 6 MIN
When Astrology Stopped Being a School
Astrology was taught at royal courts and in universities, and then the educated left it. This page lays out the record, with the grade of each claim shown in plain words.
This page asks one question. When did astrology stop being taken seriously by the learned, and why? It answers from the school's own notes, row by row.
Each claim below carries its row number from the school's notes and a grade in plain words. On record means a source you can open says it. A reading means it is the school's interpretation, not a finding. Open means the sources are missing or disagree.
Court science
In old Mesopotamia, a series of tablets called Enuma Anu Enlil paired thousands of sky signs with predicted outcomes for the king and the land (E1.03, on record).
The omens give predictions. They are not a log of what then happened (E1.04, on record).
Court scholars wrote reports to the Assyrian king that quoted these omens against the sky they saw. The dated ones run from 708 to 648 BCE (E1.05, on record).
The Babylonian Diaries kept the sky, the weather, the river and the prices of goods side by side, from 652 to 61 BCE (E1.06, on record).
The craft and the universities
Ptolemy defended astrology around 150 to 170 CE by comparing it to a physician's forecast, to navigation and to weather forecasting (E1.08, on record).
University teaching of astrology is documented from the early 1300s (E1.10, on record). A 2017 doctoral thesis says it was hard to find a major European university without it after 1400 (E1.11, on record).
Kepler cast horoscopes and in 1610 published a defense of a reformed astrology (E1.12, on record).
“Credentials are not proof. Longevity is not proof.”
MAGUS: The Ontology of One
The turn
In 1586 Pope Sixtus V condemned judicial astrology in a bull and ordered astrology books handed over (E1.13, on record).
A historian's summary says the aim was to deny that the stars could incline people toward future actions (E1.14, on record). That is a claim of faith, not a test result.
Whether forecasts for farming, sailing and medicine stayed allowed after 1586 is open. Two sources point different ways, and neither full text was read (E1.14b, open).
In 1631 Urban VIII made it a capital crime to predict the life or death of the sitting pope or his close relatives (E1.15, on record).
England: the learned leave, the public stays
In England, William Lilly served about 2,000 clients between 1644 and 1666. His almanac sold about 30,000 copies a year at its height (E1.16, on record).
Astrology was still taught in some schools in the 1680s, and gone from university courses by the early 1700s (E1.17, on record).
A critic of 1667 used the old religious charge, that astrology drew obedience away from God (E1.18, on record). The 2017 thesis finds the attacks after 1650 repeated attacks made before (E1.19, on record).
The public did not leave. The thesis finds no real sign of a general fall in almanac sales, and one almanac sold about 30,000 copies a year in the 1700s (E1.21, on record).
One standard for every side
The modern tests came much later. A 1985 study in the journal Nature found natal chart predictions no better than chance (E1.23, on record, from a summary page; the paper itself was not read).
A 1975 statement against astrology had 186 signers (E1.22, on record). A statement is an opinion, not a test.
One reading of the record: in England the standing fell between about 1650 and 1720, some 265 years before the controlled tests. The causes on record before 1720 are faith, law, ridicule and politics (E1.24, a reading).
Whether the new physics of the late 1600s caused the fall is open. No source for that line was read (E1.26, open).
Held to one standard, each side gets the grade of what it did. The craft claimed a working science. The Church and the critics made claims of faith. In this list, only the 1985 test is a measured result.
“Astrology, as presented in this paper, does not claim that the planets cause human events.”
On Astrology: The Recipe for Reality
Words used here
- On record
- A source you can open says it. The grade is for what the source says, not a promise that the source is right.
- A reading
- The school's interpretation of the record. It is held as a reading and never stated as fact.
- Open
- Not found, or the sources disagree. An open row is a question, not a claim.
- Judicial astrology
- Reading the sky for the events and choices of people's lives, as opposed to weather, farming or sailing.
- Almanac
- A yearly booklet of the calendar, the sky and forecasts, sold cheaply to the public.
THE WORKING · TONIGHT
Five minutes on paper.
- Pick one belief you hold about astrology, for it or against it.
- Write where it came from: a person, a book, a video or your own record.
- Give it one of the three grades from this page: on record, a reading or open.
- If it is open, write what source or what test of your own would settle it.
Read the note again in a week and see whether the grade still fits.
Questions to sit with
- Which of your views on astrology rests on a test, and which rests on a reputation?
- Why might the public have kept buying almanacs after the learned left? Keep your answer graded as a reading.
- What would one standard for both sides ask of you?
The quoted lines come from the MAGUS books named under each one. Test it in your own life. Keep what holds.
Your marks stay in this browser only. Nothing is sent to us.
Next.
The fall in England came without a ban. The next page looks at the places where rulers did pass laws about who could read the sky.
The free book is MAGICK, An Introduction.